Author Martha Southgate recently wrote an essay called "Writers Like Me" for the New York Times Sunday Book Review. In the piece, she ponders why there aren't more serious, literary black writers in her age bracket (she's 46) when there seems to be plenty white ones. She writes:These days, there are only a few names of black authors born in the United States, beyond Morrison's, that the average reader of serious fiction might easily drop - Colson Whitehead, ZZ Packer, Edward P. Jones. Of these three, only Jones is over 40.
But black authors writing in an ambitious, thoughtful way about American subjects are harder to find - even when they do get published.
So Southgate, who is the author of three novels, does a little investigation and comes up with a few reasons.
One is pretty much racism.
Another is the fact that many blacks aren't afforded the same sort of financial cushion/security of their white counterparts to pursue an uncertain career in writing. She uses the example of Edward P. Jones, author of the Pulitzer-Prize winning novel THE KNOWN WORLD. Jones published his first book, LOST IN THE CITY, in 1992 at the age of 41. Although it was critically-acclaimed (it really is a fabulous book), he returned to his job at a magazine where he worked for the next ten years before he was laid off. He wrote THE KNOWN WORLD in six months although he thought about it for ten years. His response to why he didn't make the leap to full-time writer sooner was:
"If you're born poor or you're born working-class, a job is important. People who are born with silver spoons in their mouths never have to worry. They know someone will take care of them. Worrying about not having a job would have put a damper on any creativity that I would have had. So I'm glad I had that job."
Another reason Southgate uncovered regarding why there aren't more serious black writers is low book sales. If people aren't buying books by these types of writers, publishers aren't responding by publishing more of them. A simple, yet hurtful fact of supply and demand.
Truth is, Southgate is a fabulous writer. I loved her most recent book THIRD GIRL FROM THE LEFT and after I read it, I wondered why she wasn't more popular. Why didn't more people know her name or her work. Why isn't she a bestselling writer?
And how many writers like her are getting lost in the cracks? How many other great writers aren't getting the shine, respect, and book sales they deserve? And how much is the black community supporting our talented wordsmiths writing in any genre (not just literary fiction)?
Southgate ends her essay by writing:
It saddens me to think of the dreams that have been ditched, the stories that haven't been told because of racism, because of fear and economic insecurity, because that first novel didn't move enough copies. I hope to see the day when there are more of us at the party (and the parties), when the work of African-Americans who tell our part of the American story well receives the celebration, and the sales, it deserves.
Click here to read the entire essay.
Comments: (51)
Add a comment
By: xzavier on 7/10/2007 4:55PM
ui think cause of the content/topic(s) and subject matter is to deep/ real/ extreme for for non- black races to appreciate or relate to. I've notice that a lot of black writes deleiver/ create in such a manner that it can be veiwed as races, intimidating, embarrassing to n a lot of other races. I think another reason black writer s have such a hard time is they target their writing tothe balck audience. another reason , their are nt just a lot of black that are reading or have literal taste.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Lorraine Elijah Brown on 7/03/2007 3:19PM
You are so correct, Martha. Large publishing company will million for Blacks who are willing to degrade Blacks by use of the "N" word. They are willing to pay Whites in advance to go into the black community and research on famous black people or a story on the hood. What we need is more American-American publishing houses. We need to get started immediately. I started writing years ago, and received mail stating that the publishing company only accept one of two authors by Blacks. Don't worry, soon or later the people in this country will know the truth, once they realize the craps they been reading.
There are many, African-American, like myself with manuscripts from four generation of unpublished work.
This is a shame, when Whites had been controlling the market. Time for a change.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: maggie on 7/03/2007 4:19PM
I read a lot of literary/writer magazines and so-called "Top Selling" book reviews and I can't remember any of the names above being mentioned other than Edward P. Jones. The only reason I knew about Martha Southgate was by reading a now defunct blog by Danyel Smith, which I miss by the way.
In reference to low book sales, I've noticed one of the major complaints I keep reading about -- from "black" and "white" consumers/writers -- is how the books are segregated in book stores. For example, if you're a "white" consumer just looking for a book from someone whose been classified as a Sci-Fi writer -- such as, say, Octavia Butler -- you may not think to go to a "black"/African-American section; you're just thinking Sci-Fi.
Moneywise, I'll try to do my part and dig a little deeper to find these authors and support them.
Keep up the good work by the way. I've added a bunch of books to my Wish List since I found this blog. :-)
Peace
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Edgi on 7/03/2007 5:30PM
I am a black writer and I, too, see that Ms. Southgate has a valid point: the absence of a financial safety net discourages many aspiring black authors. Furthermore, the literary market itself is not welcoming to black writers, especially those of us blacks who take the leap to innovate, not imitate the stereotypical. I can't tell you how SICK I AM of perusing the bookshelves and finding the same old sh*t. These white-owned companies keep telling us what we want to read; they NEVER ASK what we want or do a market testing. I am thankful that Ms. Southgate has commented on exactly what I have known all along.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Cecil Jones on 7/03/2007 5:45PM
I can't call myself a writer, but I've offered a book of simple political poetry with the story behind it. I can't get published because of the Patriot Act. I used all the "Buzz Words" and I talked about all the right people. Walt Whitman predicted that a simple cosmic poet would come along to explain the complex politics of our day. I'm the man! I led the drive to impeach President Clinton and I went "Toe to Toe" with President Bush. The book can't miss if it gets published. Where do I go?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: ayomide on 7/03/2007 6:19PM
I would love it if there were more serious african american writers. I agree with what said above but I think now the push is for books that talk about the ghetto or erotic books. That's all I see. I went into Barnes and Nobles looking for a good read and saw an entire table dedicated to this type of literature. I was so offended. As if that all we have to offer. I give props to Zane for her stuff but now we are flooded with these type of books.
It almost saddens me by what is said about getting published. I have start writing and I haven't had the pleasure of trying to get published yet. But I will still try when I am finished.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Lorraine Elijah Brown on 7/03/2007 7:40PM
I'm with you on that, Edgi. I'm sick as well. Many Africa-American are sick. We were sick when we had to read in elementary school books about Dick and Jane and Sally. It got so bad that the word Dick is now a bad word. We would write it on the walls about Dick and Jane. The funny thing about it all, is that Whites don't know what I'm talking about when I say,"Dick."
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Dumane on 7/04/2007 12:36AM
I love your blog! YOU ARE SOOOOOO RIGHT!!!!! My reading has gone down 90% since the 80's. You have to write about crack love stories set in a project just to get published or it has to be negative stuff on black men. There is nothing to read anymore. If your a foreign black (like this black woman from Arrica) who wrote a book of lies and the publishers and government of the U.S. gave her a cool million and she came over and trashed blacks in America!!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: David Reese El on 7/04/2007 1:35AM
it is a sadness that Africian American's do not have
the same gates and doors widely open in all aspects
of our lives. i think that our story in America and
in the country from which we came is an enlightened
one one of color and substance it should be read and
recognized by all American citizens' and the like
exspecially by us. we dare and do wonderous things we
have the intelligence the creative minds to write to be
successful. not only that we have strength to overcome
any obstacles and fears. we need to believe in ourselves and our race to succeed.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Dumane on 7/04/2007 1:04AM
Keep on writing and telling it. You have the best blog on BV. I wish more BV bloggers spoke to the soul of blacks the way you can. You keep ot up!!!!! Write on, dont stop and thank you for doing God's work. There's hope for our race yet!
Reply to this Comment | Report This