"...when our schools get all the money they need and the air force has to hold a bake sale to buy a bomber." I saw this on a bumper sticker a few months ago. I've gotta get myself one of those!
No matter how painfully annoying it is to watch Hillary Swank try to keep a beat while bobbing her head to Tupac's 'Keep Your Head Up,' this story is sure to hit home for many of us. 'Freedom Writers' is a good reminder that our public education system continues to fail us... miserably.
I remember being pushed through the bureaucratic chaos of public school. During my freshman year of high school I was failing most of my classes. Little did I know that there was only one thing that mattered to the school administration -- my test scores. They had to do something to try to keep me -- any everyone just like me -- on track. "Get good grades, get paid." That was the unofficial slogan for a pilot program that was brought into my high school. While the thought of getting paid $50 for every 'A' I earned sounded good, even that wasn't enough to motivate me into coming to class. I understood that I was being taught to memorize rather than learn. But as long as students tested well in school, teachers weren't facing pay-cuts from their already below-average salaries, and unfortunately this was, is, and will likely continue to be the bottom line.
It's easy to play the blame game, but in reality there are so many factors as to why this system has failed us. We can start with the government, who has placed emphasis on spending for weapons and security as opposed to resources for our youth and future leaders. We can move on to the teachers and school administrators who care only to follow along with class curriculum and make it through the day. And we can end with the parents who have swept their kids out the door to be raised by the streets. This is the cycle, and the message that 'Freedom Writers' makes a good effort to deliver.
The film was a testament to what we've known all along; our kids can't be expected to succeed in substandardsocial conditions, especially when they are forced through a public school system that expects them (and ultimately sets them up) to fail miserably in the end. Looking past the dialogue (which sounded more like a compilation of refrigerator magnet quotes) and overworked inspirational scenes, I can appreciate the real life Erin Gruwell for her unobstructedeffort to change the way these kids perceived education and their own capabilities. Frankly I could care less about the cliché 'white teacher saves the day again' story line. If there were more Erin Gruwell's in this system, we would be making some serious progress towards educating our youth beyond tests.
Controversial author and educator Akil put it best in his recent writings, which I have embraced and I respect him for his forthright honesty: "Just because the student has "memorized" information, doesn't indicate that the student has developed the ability to think, intellectualize, contemplate, or mentally problem solve. This "memorization" is not mind-development; it is mind programming. This memorization doesn't train a person to use their mind as a productive tool at all, it just uses the mind as a dysfunctional empty bucket to hold irrelevant information."
Posted by celiaherrera12
Comments: (7)
Add a comment
By: msbronzebeatmakr on 1/09/2007 9:53PM
What happened to the orginal quote by Akil?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Makese73 on 1/10/2007 6:40PM
EVERYONE should see this film, it is inspirational!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Brownsu243 on 1/11/2007 3:09PM
I am 67 years old, and I was fortunate to have had a very intelligent mother who was an avid reader. I inherited my love of reading from her. I was also born before the age of television. In either case, my mother stressed that her children read well(my sister, my brother and I)!! When my son was born, I too made sure that he could read well (he was always 2 grades above his level)! I am saying this because I believe that the parents should play a large role in educating their children! Children start learning at home first!! It is important that you read to them...that they are exposed to newspapers, magazine and books. My earliest memory was reading the cache of Reader's Digests that my mother had. She always said that reading was the key to all education! That even if you didn't go to school, you could go to the library and read every book in it and acquire an education!! Yes, it is important that the children get the best tools possible to learn, I believe that, but the parents must ber involved too. I know most parents work today, but you owe your children the best education you can afford, you pay taxes make them give your child what you pay for!! This is one of the richest and most advanced countries on earth, why should we have illiterate children in this day and age?
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Nico K on 1/19/2007 5:53PM
This is a very redundant typical white woman saving some inner city kid story lines that is so tiring and starting to look like raicst propaganda. There's many black teachers who should have their story told. Tired of these Dangerous Minds-knock off films and many of the brother and sistas that I spoke with feel exactly the same way. Hillary Swank should make a film about the public school system in america's trailer parks since she is from one. On the real!
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: krysten on 1/22/2007 8:20PM
I think everyone should go see this wonderful movie to see the hardships kids face these days. It WILL make you cry. Everybody in the movie did such a good job acting and I would not mind going to watch it again, its just that good and inspiring-you could learn from this movie.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: cheryl on 2/02/2007 7:21PM
Nico....your arguement is valid but, your delivery of it was narrow-minded and hmmmmmm...UH redundant!! You could have gotten your point across without the insults..I'll be watching to see something conducive to education with your name on it.
Reply to this Comment | Report This
By: Cassandra on 2/27/2007 2:47PM
HO-HUM.....YET ANOTHER BRAVE HEROIC WHITE PERSON CARING AND DETERMINED ENOUGH TO GO AGAINST "THEIR" IMPLEMENTED "MONORITY EDUCATION GENOCIDE PROGRAMS" TO HELP "US" TO ACHEIVE LORD! THIS WHITE WOMAN GONNA SAVE US FROM HER WHITE SYSTEM!!TELL ME...IS POSSIBLE TO BE BOTH THE PROBLEM AND THE SOLUTION AT THE SAME TIME?? "HELL NO". I WON'T BE VIEWING THIS FLICK EVEN WHEN IT PREMIERES ON FREE TV.
Reply to this Comment | Report This